Home > Uncategorized > Toward a more thoughtful conversation on stories

Toward a more thoughtful conversation on stories


I’ve become increasingly concerned about the quality of discourse in comments on news stories on Reuters.com and on other major news sites.  On some stories,  the “conversation”  has been little more than  partisans slinging invective at each other under  the cloak of anonymity.


I believe our time-challenged, professional readers want to see a more rewarding conversation—and my colleagues who lead Reuters.com are introducing a new process for comments that I believe will help bring that about.


The new process, which gives special status to readers whose comments have passed muster in the past, won’t address the anonymity issue, but I do think it is an important step toward a more civil and thoughtful conversation.


Let me introduce Richard Baum, Reuters Global Editor for Consumer Media, to tell you about the new process:


——————————————————————————————


Like many major news publishers, we’ve agonized over how to balance our enthusiasm for reader comments on stories with our belief that few people would benefit from a free-for-all. Most of our readers respect our request for comments that “advance the story,” by submitting relevant anecdotes, links and data or by challenging our reporting when they think we’ve fallen short of our editorial standards. It’s rewarding, sometimes even exhilarating, to see the way our audience builds on our coverage.


Where we struggle is with comments that we believe contribute nothing useful to the conversation. I’m not talking about obscenities and spam — we have software that aims to block the publication of those — but something more subjective. Most of our readers are business professionals who value their time highly. We believe they want comments that are as rewarding to read as they are to write. The challenge is how we deliver that experience in a way that doesn’t delay the publication of good comments nor use up resources that might be better deployed on other parts of the site.


I’ll explain how we’re tackling that shortly. But first, here are some examples of the type of comments that fall foul of our moderators:
– racism and other hate language that isn’t caught by our software filters
– obscene words with letters substituted to get around the software filters
– semi-literate spelling; we’re not looking for perfection, but people shouldn’t have to struggle to determine the meaning
– uncivil behavior towards other commentators; debate is welcome, schoolyard taunts are not
– incitement to violence
– comments that have nothing to do with the story
– comments that have been pasted across multiple stories
– comments that are unusually long, unless they’re very well written
– excessive use of capital letters


Some of the guidelines for our moderators are hard to define precisely. Mocking of public people can be fair sport, for example, but a moderator that has just approved 30 comments calling someone an idiot can rightly decide that there’s little incremental value in publishing the 31st. When we block comments of this nature, it’s because of issues of repetition, taste or legal risk, not political bias.


Until recently, our moderation process involved editors going through a basket of all incoming comments, publishing the ones that met our standards and blocking the others. (It’s a binary decision: we don’t have the resources to edit comments.)


This was unsatisfactory because it delayed the publication of good comments, especially overnight and at weekends when our staffing is lighter.


Our new process grants a kind of VIP status on people who have had comments approved previously. When you register to comment on Reuters.com, our moderation software tags you as a new user. Your comments go through the same moderation process as before, but every time we approve a comment, you score a point.


Once you’ve reached a certain number of points, you become a recognized user. Congratulations: your comments will be published instantly from now on. Our editors will still review your comments after they’ve been published and will remove them if they don’t meet our standards. When that happens, you’ll lose points. Lose enough points and you’ll revert to new user status.


The highest scoring commentators will be classified as expert users, earning additional privileges that we’ll implement in future. You can see approval statistics for each reader on public profile pages like this, accessed by clicking on the name next to a comment.


It’s not a perfect system, but we believe it’s a foundation for facilitating a civil and rewarding discussion that’s open to the widest range of people. Let me know what you think.

Philips 52PFL5605H/12 132,1 cm (52 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C) schwarz Grundlegende 3m High Speed HDMI Kabel mit Ethernet – (1.4a Version, 15.2Gbps) HDMI auf HDMI Kabel mit Et… Toshiba 32RL838G 81 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz AMR, DVB-T/-C, CI+) silber Thomson 22FS5246C 55,9 cm (22 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, DVB-C/-T Tuner) schwarz Panasonic Viera TX-L32DT30E 80 cm (32 Zoll) 3D LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 400Hz bls, DVB-T/-C/-S,… Panasonic Viera TX-P50GT30E 127 cm (50 Zoll) 3D-NeoPlasma-Fernseher (Full-HD, 600Hz sfd, DVB-T/-C/-S, CI… Toshiba 32SL733G 81,3 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C) schwarz Philips 32PFL5605H/12 81,3 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C) schwarz CMX LED 8156 39,6 cm (15,6 Zoll) 16:9 HD-Ready LED-Backlight Fernseher mit integriertem DVB-T Tuner schwarz Wandhalterung 26-55 Zoll bzw. 66-140 cm LCD Monitor Schwenkarm Wandhalterung kipp/schwenk/rotierbar geeignet für 25-58cm (10-23″) Displays Philips 32PFL7605H/12 81,3 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, Ambilight Spectra 2, DV… Samsung UE 32 B 6000 VPXZG 81,3 cm (32 Zoll) 16:9 Full-HD LCD-Fernseher mit LED-Backlight mit integriert… Acer S221HQLBD 54,6 cm (21,5 Zoll) slim LED Monitor (DVI,VGA, Kontrast 12.000.000:1, 5ms Reaktionszeit) … Philips 53640945 Livingcolors MINI WEISS EMEA LED-Ambiente-Wohn- Leuchte weiss Acer AT2358MLW 58,4 cm (23 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, DVB-T/C, CI+, HDMI, USB) hochglanz weiss Philips Master LED Bulb 8W/220V E-27 dimmbar warmweiß Acer K330 3D LED Projektor (Kontrast 4000:1, WXGA, 500 ANSI Lumen, HDMI, USB-A) Thomson 26HS5246C 66 cm (26 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (HD-Ready, DVB-C/-T Tuner) schwarz LG LD15X740P2B.D00GWE0 LED Downlight 6 Zoll 15 W 4000K LG 42LV570S 107 cm (42 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 500Hz MCI, Smart TV, DVB-T/C/S ,CI+) schwarz Sony Bravia KDL-46EX720BAEP 117 cm (46 Zoll) 3D-LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, Motionflow XR 200Hz, D… Toshiba 46SL863G 117 cm (46 Zoll) LED-Backlight Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S/-S2, CI+) schwarz Auto-Subwoofer 25cm (10″) Crunch GPX10BP 600W LED Hama Lautstärkebegrenzer für TV Asus VE278Q 68,6 cm (27 Zoll) widescreen TFT Monitor (LED, HDMI,DVI,VGA, 2ms Reaktionszeit) schwarz LG 47LV5500 119 cm (47 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 500 Hz MCI, DVB-T/C, CI+, Smart TV) schwarz Acer C110 LED-Projektor (Kontrast 1000:1, 50 ANSI Lumen, WVGA 854×480) Philips 40PFL5806K/02 102 cm (40 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 200Hz PMR, DVB-T/C/S, Smart TV)… Panasonic DMP-BDT110EG 3D Blu-ray-Player (Upscaler 1080p, HDMI, Apple iPod touch fernbedienbar, WLAN rea… PLasma LCD LED TV Wandhalterung Doppelarm ausziehbar für 24” 26” 27” 30” 32” 37” passend für Samsu… LG LD25X730P2B.D00GWE0 LED Downlight 6 Zoll 23 W 3000K Samsung UE32D6510WSXZG 80 cm (32 Zoll) 3D-LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 200Hz, DVB-C/-T/-S2) weiß LG 37LV3550 93,9 cm (37 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/-C, CI+) schwarz Women Who Led the Way: Eight Pioneers for Equal Rights Toshiba 40VL748G 101,6 cm (40 Zoll) Slim LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S) klavierla… Wandhalterung 32-42 Zoll bzw.81-107 cm Philips LED Kerzen IMAGEO TeaLight 6ER LG M237WDP-PC 58,4 cm (23 Zoll) TFT Monitor (VGA, DVI, HMDI, Reaktionszeit 5ms, TV-Tuner) Toshiba 19DL834G 47 cm (19 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (HD-Ready, 50Hz, DVB-T/-C, CI+) weiß Samsung UE55C6700 139,7 cm (55 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S2) anthrazit-sc… Lunartec Alu-Schreibtisch-Lampe “Vélivole” mit 48 Power-LEDs (6.500K) – Die Designerlampe aus Leichtmeta… Sharp Aquos LC 46 LE 600 E 116,8 cm (46 Zoll) Full-HD LCD-Fernseher mit LED-Backlight mit integriertem D… Philips 37PFL8605K/02 94 cm (37 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 200Hz, Ambilight Spectra 2, DVB-… Acer AT2758ML 68,6 cm (27 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, DVB-T/C, CI+, HDMI, USB) hochglanz sch… Designer Habitat – Schwenkbare LCD Plasmafernseher Wandhalterung (13 – 37 Zoll) für alle VESA Lochabstän… Philips PTA01 WiFi Dongle für 7000er/8000er Serie 2010, Heimkino-Systeme HTS9520, 9140, 5220, Blu-ray Pl… Samsung UE 46 B 6000 VPXZG 116,8 cm (46 Zoll) 16:9 Full-HD LCD-Fernseher mit LED-Backlight mit integrier… LG 32LE5300 81 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/-C) schwarz TV Das Original Tageslichtleuchte Daylight

  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: