Home > Uncategorized > GLG: Italy and Greece deserve a central bank

GLG: Italy and Greece deserve a central bank

If Emerging Markets is any guide, the problem with this narrative is not just that it is wrong, but downright dangerous in its policy implications.  The tyrannical hold of this perspective on European policy making is pushing the continent down the path of a historic pro-cyclical fiscal contraction almost as the be all and end all of crisis response.  There is already a mountain of evidence that this has not worked, whatever the merits of debt reduction and ideological divisions on its pace and timing.  The missing ingredient has always been and remains today, quite different.  Italy and Greece lack a central bank.  More importantly, they deserve one, desperately.

For an economy where paper money is the medium of exchange and fractional reserve banking exists where a bank transforms a unit of deposits into a multiple of that in loans, a central bank is essential.  This is as true of Switzerland as it is of Greece.  It performs a function of lender of last resort to prevent a rapid run on an otherwise solvent bank (a liquidity crisis) from turning into a solvency one for that bank or for the entire banking system.  When Italy and Greece signed onto the Euro, they had a legitimate right to expect that the Central Banks they were giving up would be replaced by a common Eurozone one, which would in effect perform the same function for their economies.  What they got instead was a Central Bank which is constrained by mandate, and German objection to its modification, from performing that function for anyone but Germany.

In the Eurozone, not only are the ECB’s clients the member state banks, but also the sovereigns.  We are in the advanced stages of a full blown and contagious run on both, with the ECB for all intents and purposes on the sidelines.  Whatever support it has provided so far in the guise of purchases of distressed member state debt and bank liquidity provision has been trivial in relation to the size of the run, and communicated in such a tentative way as to aggravate it, by signalling impotence.  The ECB’s absence, whatever its legal justifications, has effectively reduced Italy and Greece, not to mention the Eurozone, to the status of a barter economy.

Italians and Greeks can and should justifiably ask for redress.  They did not give up their Liras and Drachmas to be put through a fiscal vice as the cost of the most basic central banking services being provided them, any more than U.S. states did for the same service from the Federal Reserve.  The lender of last resort function is a relatively uncontroversial one, which has little to do with ideological debates about the desirability or effectiveness of active monetary policy or with Weimer Republic-induced phobias of hyperinflation and money printing.  The idea, that in the middle of a full-blown bank/sovereign run, a central bank’s intervention would be made conditional on preceding actions, fiscal or otherwise, that are subject to political vagaries, is extraordinary and dangerous.

A confidence crisis is precisely that; it cannot wait and must be dealt with decisively and conclusively if the vicious cycle is to be arrested.  This is not to say that the fiscal and debt problems which challenged confidence to begin with should not be addressed; they should.  However, in this European version of the Emerging Markets archetype, we are in now well beyond the phase where a medium term fiscal adjustment announced by technocratic governments in Greece or Italy will have any effect.  It maybe part of the solution, but it is certainly not sufficient, or the most urgent issue.  The ECB needs to act and act big.

Periphery Eurozone states have a legitimate existential grievance that has gone essentially unnoticed in the current crisis narrative.  They were not admitted into the Eurozone merely out of German altruism.  Germany may pretend otherwise but it derives a clear benefit from not having Italy and Spain devalue at its expense, as they used to with regularity in the past.  For these countries to be condemned to a decade-long common monetary policy, where rates were set to suit larger economies like Germany, and subsequently a global financial crisis, where their right to a lender of last resort function is denied, is laughable.  In fact, the fiscal union altar on which the ECB and bailout is conditional is itself a canard.  Both Germany and France were in violation of the Stability Pact 3 percent budget deficit rule and conveniently gave themselves exemptions.  Spain today has a public debt to GDP ratio some 20 percentage points below Germany’s.

This is not a story of German benevolence and peripheral European excess.  It is a story of extraordinarily poor institutional design, for which a read of Emerging Markets history might be instructive.  Italians and Greeks should demand that the ECB start acting like their central bank, and have its legal framework modified if need be to do so.  Their argument should be simple, if it does not, it will become nobody’s central bank, because there will no longer be a Eurozone.

LG 42LE8500 106,7 cm (42 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 200Hz MCI, DVB-T/-C) schwarz Toshiba E-Core E14 LED-Kerze dimmbar Klar 250 lm Highways Into History Ten Trails of Discovery That Led American Pioneers on Their Journey to Nationhood Samsung UE40C6700 101,6 cm (40 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S2) anthrazit-sc… Toshiba 40WL768G 101,6 cm (40 Zoll) Slim 3D-LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 200Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S, WLAN, … LMP LED GU10 Toshiba MR16 8,5W dim. Philips SFL 5561 3 LED (0,5mm) Outdoor Taschenlampe inkl. Batterien Beleuchtetes Bild mit LED Grösse: 30x30cm von Mr.Krieger Brunnen Toshiba 32DL834G 80 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (50Hz AMR, DVB-T/-C/-S, CI+) schwarz LG 37LW4500 81 cm (32 Zoll) Cinema 3D LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 400Hz MCI, DVB-T/C, CI+, USB 2.0… Acer S222HQLAbid 54,6 cm (21,5 Zoll) slim LED Monitor (VGA, DVI, HDMI, Kontrast 12.000.000:1, Reaktionsz… LED Adventskranz-Kerzen LED Adventskerzen-Set Kerzenset Adventskranz Weihnachtskerzen LED Lichter Sony Bravia KDL-40EX720BAEP 102 cm (40 Zoll) 3D-LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, Motionflow XR 200Hz, D… LOGILINK USB to MIDI Adapter Kabel 2,0m Philips 26PFL3405H/12 66 cm (26 Zoll) LED Fernseher (HD-ready, 50Hz, Digital Crystal Clear, DVB-T) Wandhalterung Wandhalter universal nur 2,5cm Wandabstand für 37 40 46 42 50 52 60 63 Zoll 75kg Farbe sch… LG 47LE5300 119,4 cm (47 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/-C) schwarz CMX LED 8247F AT Ozelot-Serie 61 cm (24 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full HD, DVB-T) schwarz LG E2750V-PN 68,5 cm (27 Zoll) widescreen TFT Monitor (HDMI, DVI, VGA, 5ms Reaktionszeit) schwarz Acer C20 Silver Edition LED-Projektor (Kontrast 2000:1, 20 ANSI Lumen, WVGA 854 x 480 Pixel) silber Samsung UE 40 B 6000 VPXZG 101,6 cm (40 Zoll) 16:9 Full-HD LCD-Fernseher mit LED-Backlight mit integrier… TOSHIBA LED E27 3,5W WW 24000h GLÜHL Samsung SyncMaster XL2370 LED 58,4 cm (23 Zoll) TFT Monitor (VGA, DVI, Reaktionszeit 2ms) schwarz glänzend Acer Aspire TimelineX 3820TG-5464G75nks 33,7 cm (13,3 Zoll) Notebook (Intel Core i5 460M 2,5GHz, 4GB RA… LG 55LW4500 139,7 cm (55 Zoll) Cinema 3D LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T, DVB-C, CI+) sch… Philips 32PFL8605K/02 81 cm (32 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, Ambilight Spectra 2, DVB-… LG 47LW5590 119 cm (47 Zoll) Cinema 3D LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 600 Hz MCI, DVB-T/C, CI+, Smart… LG 42LV3550 106,6 cm (42 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/-C, CI+) schwarz LG 47LW5500 119,3 cm (47 Zoll) Cinema 3D LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/C, CI+) schwarz Moser Profiline Haartrockner PowerStyle Ionic, + DIFFUSER (!), schwarz, 2000W, Ionenfunktion, Kalttaste,… Thomson 24FS5246C 61 cm (24 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, DVB-C/-T Tuner) schwarz Spyder3TV Multilingual PLasma LCD LED TV Wandhalterung Doppelarm ausziehbar für 32” 37″ 40″ 42″ 46″ 47″ 50″ 51″ 55″ 60″ passen… Acer K 10 LED-Projektor (Kontrast 2000:1, 100 ANSI Lumen, SVGA 800 x 600 Pixel) Philips Power LED 3W GU10 Spot, hell wie 35W Halogen weiß 3000K Philips 442270100036 LIVING COLORS FROSTED WHITE LED-Ambiente-Wohn- Leuchte Panasonic Viera TX-L24C3E 61 cm (24 Zoll) LCD-Fernseher (HD-Ready, 50Hz, DVB-T/-C, CI+) klavierlack-schwarz Panasonic Viera TX-L42U3E 106 cm (42 Zoll) LCD-Fernseher (Full-HD, 50Hz, DVB-T/-C, CI+) schwarz When All Roads Led to Tombstone: A Memoir Toshiba 32AV833G 81 cm (32 Zoll) LCD-Fernseher (HD-Ready, 50Hz, DVB-T/-C, CI+) schwarz 5m Hochgeschwindigkeits-HDMI-Kabel mit Ethernet mit 90° (rechtwinkligem) Stecker und Audiorückkanal (Aud… LG HS200G LED-Projektor (Kontrast 2000:1, 200 ANSI Lumen, SVGA 800x 600 Pixel) Moser Profiline Haartrockner PowerStyle Ionic, 2000W, schwarz, Ionenfunktion, 2 Geschwindigkeiten, 4 Hei… 2 x UNIVERSAL 3D SHUTTER 3D BRILLE FÜR SONY, Panasonic, Samsung (LCD/LED), LG, Philips, Sharp, Toshiba, … LG 37LV4500 94 cm (37 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/C, CI+) schwarz Acer K11 LED-Projektor (Kontrast 2000:1, 200 ANSI Lumen) Samsung UE37C6700 94 cm (37 Zoll) LED-Backlight-Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz, DVB-T/-C/-S2) anthrazit-schwarz LG LD15X730P2B.D00GWE0 LED Downlight 6 Zoll 15 W 3000K Philips LivingColors LED – Ambiente – Wohn- Leuchte LG 42LV375S 107 cm (42 Zoll) LED Backlight Fernseher (Full-HD, 100Hz MCI, DVB-T/C/S, CI+, Smart-TV) schwarz

Categories: Uncategorized Tags: , , ,
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: